A few follow-up thoughts and clarifications on my previous post, “On Wetsuits in Marathon Swimming”:
- This discussion is primarily about marathon swims - which I’ll define as swims long enough to require a support craft. In practice, this usually means swims longer than 10K. Swimmers who attempt such swims are - or should be - sufficiently skilled and experienced that drowning-prevention is not a valid excuse for using a wetsuit. (Hypothermia is a separate issue.)
- I have no problem with newcomers to open-water swimming utilizing wetsuit technology to ensure safety, to enhance comfort, and to develop confidence. I believe wetsuits encourage more people to try open-water swimming than would otherwise, and that this is positive.
- I have no problem with wetsuits in triathlon. I’m not a triathlete myself, but they’re certainly free to run their sport however they wish.
- I have no problem with swimmers of any ability using wetsuits in training swims, or leisure swims, to help them swim for longer in cold water than they would otherwise, or to extend the training season. I’ve done this myself - specifically, Rob D. My cold-water acclimation has since improved, so I’d probably make a different decision now.
- I have no problem with people using wetsuits in races in which wetsuits are specifically allowed (even encouraged) - such as many open-water races in the UK, the Nite Moves swims in Santa Barbara. It’s annoying to lose to people just because they’re wearing a wetsuit and you’re not.
- However, as I’ve said before, I believe the above policy creates an unfortunate arms-race dynamic, such that people who’d prefer not to wear wetsuits are incentivized to wear them in order to compete.
- I also understand there are parts of the world (max water temp < 15C/59F) where significant “skin” participation is simply unrealistic. Frankly, though, if they can do it in Alaska, they can do it just about anywhere.
- I have no problem with open-water races that offer separate divisions for wetsuits and “skins” - e.g., USMS-sanctioned events. In fact I think they’re great - they encourage participation by offering a wetsuit option, while avoiding an arms race.
What many marathon swimmers, including myself, have a problem with is people who specifically market themselves to the media as “marathon swimmers,” who claim to set records or pioneer new swims - yet who use artificial aids (such as wetsuits) during their swims.
In Scott’s words, it’s “wrong, wrong, wrong!”